AEROSPACE Germany’s U-2

Born to spy

There might only have been six Grob D-450 spyplanes built back in the Cold War era but, as ALAN WARNES explains, there is still plenty of life in the aircraft yet.

Grob’s single-seat G 520 taxies out at the company’s Mindelhausen airfield in southern Germany. Grob

Undoubtedly the composite-built Grob 520 is one of the most fascinating general aviation aircraft out there today. Originally designed as a U-2 type high altitude long endurance manned platform, the Grob 520 Egrett was born from a West German Air Force-US Air Force requirement in the mid-80s – the height of the Cold War.

US/German spyplane programme

Back then the airframe was labelled the Egrett; the name evolved from the three companies backing the development of the reconnaissance platform: E-Systems (for avionics – now L3Harris Technologies) based in Greenville, Texas; Grob Flugzeugbau (for airframe – now H3Grob) in southern Germany and Garrett Engines (with TPE331 turboprop engine – now Honeywell) in North Carolina, Texas. Now the Egrett name is no longer used.

E-Systems considered the Egrett programme as an ideal opportunity to develop its name and knowhow in the international marketplace, considering it as a big growth area for the company, despite the difficulties in exporting highly sensitive technologies.

The requirement by the joint West German Air Force/US Air Force programme was for up to 12 LAPAS (airborne stand-off primary reconnaissance system) aircraft. Two German pilots were even sent to Beale AFB California, for high altitude training, the home of the USAF’s 9th Strategic Reconnaissance Wing flying SR-71 and U-2s. The programme’s official purpose, which the US Air Force named Senior Guardian, was to provide a cheaper alternative to the Lockheed U-2 for both treaty verification and environmental monitoring purposes. They were supposed to fly close to the East German border with a sideways-looking airborne radar to monitor electronic traffic on the other side. 

Production

The prototype D-450 development aircraft flew on 24 June 1987, piloted by Einar Enevoldson. To prove its high altitude capabilities he set a class world record of 53,573.96ft (16,329.35m) on 1 September 1988. Two pre-production aircraft known as the D-500 Egrett II followed in 1989 and 1990, as the design edged towards certification, which came on 13 September 1991.

THE PROTOTYPE D-450 DEVELOPMENT AIRCRAFT FLEW ON 24 JUNE 1987, PILOTED BY EINAR ENEVOLDSON. TO PROVE ITS HIGH ALTITUDE CAPABILITIES, HE SET A CLASS WORLD RECORD OF 53,573.96FT

The aircraft was built to be foolproof, according to Enevoldson, a retired US Air Force pilot, who trained with the Boscombe Down based Empire Test Pilot School before joining NASA Dryden. After retiring from NASA, Enevoldson helped Grob with the design of the Egrett. He wanted an aircraft that was easy to fly, could take off in all weather, climb to 50,000ft, loiter in a race track for eight hours and then land in 20 minutes.

E-Systems owned the first example, fitted with various sensor packages, and Grob flew the second, renaming it Strato 1 to market the design to civil authorities as a resource management platform.

Following the end of the Cold War in 1990 and the unification of East and West Germany, the Luftwaffe cut its defence spending and the Egrett was cancelled. E-Systems pulled out of the project in 1993. Analysts had estimated the contract would have brought in between $600m and $1bn for E-Systems through the end of the decade.

By then five single-seat aircraft had been built, the D-450 (10001N14ES and D-FGEI) being a proof-of-concept aircraft. Unfortunately, it was scrapped in the wake of the decision to stop the order but the remaining four singleseaters and the only dual-seat aircraft are still flying. The second (10002 D-FGEE to N4510) and third aircraft (10003 was operated by E-Systems as N27ES but is now N520EG) are with Airborne Resources Inc from Midlothian, Texas, the fourth (10004 – N520DM) is with Bear Defence based in Tampa, Florida, and the fifth (10005 – D-FGRO, now D-FAHH) is still flown by H3Grob, as is the G 520T (10200 – D-FHHH) twin-seat aircraft. 

G 520T dual seater

Grob

After the LAPAS project was cancelled, Grob sold the dual-seat G 520T to the DLR (German Aerospace Centre) in Cologne, which eventually sold it onto the Flinders University of South Australia in Adelaide during 1997. Operated by the Airborne Research Australia (ARA) and registered as VH-ARA it was based at Parafield airport (18km north of Adelaide) for various scientific programmes. During a 2006 project known as the Egrett Microphysics with Extended Radiation and Lidar experiment (EMERALD-1), the Grob 520T was used to collect turbulence, heat and water vapour flux data found in cirrus clouds.

The aircraft was grounded in 2007, as there were no funds to carry out a 1,000hr inspection on the engine. Having been laid up for six years, Grob bought the aircraft back in 2013. Tom Reinert, test-pilot for Grob, flew to Parafield to supervise engineers preparing the aircraft to fly again. Tom, told the author: “We took the TPE331 engine out of the fifth G520 (10005) which had only flown around 15hr at that time and shipped it to Parafield for the dual-seater. At the same time we also upgraded the avionics in the aircraft and then I learnt to fly the aircraft in early June 2014.” He was trained by Group Captain Steve ‘Wedge’ Young, a former commander at the RAAF Edinburgh flight test centre who had flown the aircraft. Together, they planned to fly the aircraft back to Europe but, because of repeated delays when the time came, Young could not go. So Tom left Adelaide Airport on 5 June 2014 with a mechanic in the back seat for a week-long ferry that saw them fly eight legs, arriving at Grob’s Tussenhausen headquarters just west of Munich on 12 June.

The platform

Looking at the Grob 520 and its 33m (100ft) wings, and stubby fuselage it is clear that this is no normal aircraft. The modular fuselage structure is one of many reasons why this unique aircraft could be an easy-fit for today’s surveillance missions. The entire lower section is not part of the aircraft’s structure, so greatly simplifying ease of access and modification for payload configurations, all packed into the world’s only CS/FAR 23 aircraft certified to fly at 50,000ft (15kms).

The U-Bay in the centre of the lower section, also known as Bay 13, is a modular payload compartment, and Tom, a former Luftwaffe Tornado pilot, told the author: “The sensors can easily be fitted in there and connected to the bus system to power them. If you need to switch the payload, say after a first mission, all you need to do is undo the four screws to detach the compartment from the aircraft’s main structure and install a different preconfigured U-Bay with sensors.”

Grob test pilot Tom Reinert sits in the front cockpit of the Grob 520T before setting off on another mission. The Grob 520T’s analogue dials will be replaced by a GenesyS digital system in the near future. Alan WarnesThe aircraft could be used for a multitude of military surveillance missions, including the maritime role, with an appropriate maritime radar. Alternatively, it may be used for civilian applications. For example, loaded with a SATCOM, it could act as a satellite relay system during a disaster relief mission, data linking images and information to the ground.

The equipment bays are heated or cooled, as are the cockpits, to maintain a temperature-controlled environment. The bays can be configured to accept various customer payloads, such as electro-optical sensors, radar, LIDAR (Light Detection and Ranging), SIGINT (Signals Intelligence), as well as scientific/research payloads for high altitude long endurance applications. The maximum range at altitude is about 1,500m (2,800kms) but, as Tom explained “it wasn’t designed for range but for an eight-hour duration, with a typical 100kt at FL450.” The aircraft has dual GPS and is all-weather (IFR/icing) capable and dual-certified under US regulations as experimental and normal.

“To counter all the different payload weights, we have up to 100kg of ballast in the tail which we can take out when required.” Tom adds, “from an aerodynamic design with its long 33m (100ft) wings and slender fuselage the aircraft can loiter and burn little fuel.”

On flying the aircraft, Tom said: “Grob 520 pilots earn their money during the first ten minutes and last ten minutes of each sortie. The controls are heavy down low but lighter at high altitude. When on the ground it is very susceptible and has a 15kt cross wind limit. The dual seater can be steered by the nose wheel but, in the single-seater, taxiing is done by differential braking. You also have to be aware of the long wings which can flex a lot when she’s in the air and during turbulence.” 

High-flying glider tug

As part of the Airbus Perlan II experiment Airborne Resources Inc’s Arne Vasenden used his Grob 520 N5410 for the highest-ever known glider tow. Perlan II is a pressurised, two-place, space capsule with glider wings designed to use only the power of stratospheric mountain waves to fly as high as 90,000ft.”

The aircraft pulled the Airbus Perlan II from 20 August to 12 September 2018 into the skies over Patagonia, Argentina. Basically, Arne gave the Perlan II a ‘leg-up’ to the stratosphere without the glider pilots toiling for hours to get up there. After the first test flight when Vasendan took the aircraft up to just 11,000ft, to check out conditions and the new towing system customised for the G 520, the next eight went up to 40,000ft or above. During the last mission on 12 September, Vasenden took the G 520 up as high as 45,100ft, where it released the Perlan II which then climbed another 20,000ft up to 65,000ft before returning to Earth. It is probably appropriate here to mention that the Perlan project team was awarded a bronze medal by the Royal Aeronautical Society on 26 November 2018 in recognition for ‘its notable contribution to the advancement of aerospace’.

New generation modifications

The dual-seat G 520T D-FHHH is involved in payload trials and is playing a part in the aircraft’s continued evolution. The grey area below the black line is a modular payload compartment which can be detached from the aircraft. Alan Warnes

While the 1478hp Garrett TPE331-14F (flat rated to 750 SHP) is the aircraft’s current power plant, in the new generation G 520NG it would be replaced by the modern Pratt & Whitney PT-6 turboprop. It does not have the fuel benefits of the Garrett engine and only has a ceiling of 45,000ft but Tom explains why this is preferred: “We listen to our customers and the engine is a big price point for this aircraft. The original TPE331 could get you up to 50,000ft to look 250 miles beyond line of sight (BLOS), whereas the cheaper PT-6 will only fly you up to 45,000ft but you are still seeing 235 miles.” He added: “For every 5,000ft you climb, you gain 15nm of BLOS but is that worth the cost of a pressure suit and the necessary life support equipment? Our potential customers don’t think so and most don’t have the equipment to see that far anyway.”

H3Grob has modified the Grob 520T with a total-authority autopilot, thus converting it into an optionally piloted vehicle (OPV), with a side-stick installed in the rear cockpit for the first flights to control the autopilot. With Tom sitting in the aircraft as the pilot in control, the 520T was flown by an operator in the ground station or via the flight management system flight plan. Around 50hr of flight-testing has been completed so far.

The OPV gives you the option to fly the aircraft in controlled airspace with a rated pilot and, when you are in a ‘war zone’, you take the pilot out and control it from the ground

The single-seater Grob 520NG (10005 /D-FAHH) has been upgraded with a Garmin 600 digital glass cockpit and there are plans to modify the dual seater with a new GenesyS system. The optional operator console in the rear cockpit can offer two large, high resolution 23” touch screen displays, plus two foldable 12” side displays. The sensor operator can conveniently work with a full keyboard, hand controller units and a camera grip. The rear cockpit could be alternatively configured in a dual role mode for platform training or multi-pilot missions.

On the G 520NG Tom said, “We have a lead in time of 18 months to build an aircraft and we already have a mock-up built by tools we have, to verify the mould. We are optimistic that it will go into production.” But why would a customer opt for a Grob 520NG rather than say, a Global Hawk? “We are basically a lot cheaper than a Global Hawk, which costs around $280m without the sensor package, plus 20 guys to operate it. The G 520NG with sensor suite – radar systems and datalink, would probably cost a fraction of that and the big bonus for some customers is it would be ITAR free.” Tom added, “The customer could have a 24 hour persistent surveillance with three aircraft flying eight hour turns – one operating with the U-Bay sensor load, replaced by a second with a similar configuration while the third is being fitted with first aircraft’s U-Bay load.”

There is still a lot of life left in this design, 33 years after the first aircraft made its first flight. Today’s Grob 520NG could easily fulfil the ISR needs of air forces not blessed with a massive budget and secondly its non-ITAR. More countries, particularly in the Middle East, are now leaning towards nonUS-produced systems in order to get around the burdensome restrictions imposed by the US.

The Route to Air Power 2040, RAeS Conference – 6-7 October 2020