SPACEFLIGHT Space Net Zero conference report

Tackling net zero from space

The space sector is set to play a major role in the world’s net zero ambitions, not only in satellites measuring climate change and holding polluters to account but, even in potentially supplying zero-carbon energy from space. TIM ROBINSON FRAeS, reports from the RAeS Towards a Space-enabled Net Zero Earth conference, held in April.

NASA

We are currently at a tipping point with regards to space and climate change’. That was the stark message that opened the RAeS Towards a Space-enabled Net Zero Earth hybrid conference, held on 26/27 April in London with a wide range of speakers from the space industry, NGOs, start-ups and academia. Indeed, as Andrew Stanniland, CEO, Thales Alenia Space UK, noted in his welcome, climate change is the “one common topic” that unites the diverse global space industry, from launch providers to data scientists.

However, despite this consensus, there is no time to lose, according to Professor Mark Maslin, University College London in his opening keynote speech, who pointed out that the world needs to reduce emissions by 45% within ten years to meet the goals set out from last year’s COP26 climate summit. For those who remain unconvinced, Maslin said that ‘doing nothing’ about climate change could cost 20% of the world’s GDP by 2050, compared with spending 1% of GDP now to prevent it.

Above right: SatelliteVu’s thermal space imagery can monitor the energy output of individual buildings.

A new era of space EO

Key to measuring the speed of global climate change, and assessing progress in slowing the rise in global temperatures are Earth observation (EO) satellites which are now opening up new horizons in the fidelity, precision and sheer scope of climate data recorded. Professor John Remedios, Director, National Centre for Earth Observation, told the conference that today “is the dawning of the space age for climate data”. He said that it was a massive change from even only 10-15 years ago when satellite EO data was seen as a ‘potential’ advance.

This view was echoed by Dr Anna Hogg, Associate Professor, University of Leeds and Chair of the Earth Observation Working Group, Space Academic Network, who said that satellite EO had “‘revolutionised our understanding” of the polar regions with ESA’s Sentinel-1 SAR satellite, launched in 2014 collecting the same amount of ice data in Antarctica across 14 months that previous sats in the 1990s took a whole decade to acquire.

FOR SPACE TO SUPPORT SUSTAINABILITY ON EARTH, THERE NEEDS TO BE SUSTAINABILITY IN SPACE AND, TO BE BLUNT, WE ARE MOVING IN THE WRONG DIRECTION HERE.
Rajeev Suri
CEO, Inmarsat

However, as well as large governmental and national EO satellites, such as ESA’s BIOMASS, Copernicus and the like, the conference heard how this effort is now being joined by commercial EO satellites and space companies with a large number of smaller and cheaper satellites set to be launched.

Stephen Ward, from Australia’s Symbios, told delegates there is an “absolute revolution” in EO satellites, with more that 50 companies announcing plans for over 1,800 EO sats – the vast majority being under 50kg. Meanwhile, satellite operator, Planet, with its constellation of mini-sats, has already opened up access to its 5m resolution imagery dataset of forests to NGO and climate researchers.

Trust, but verify

The increased capabilities of these new EO satellites that are now coming into service mean that it is not just possible to detect large climate and weather trends, such as ice coverage in the polar regions for space, but also now to drill down to monitor the heat output of individual buildings or monitor methane leaks. This is extremely valuable not only in highlighting ‘greenwashing’ by companies paying lip service to climate action pledges, but also in assisting those industries that truly want to go green, cut their energy use and save money.

THE ABILITY TO HARNESS SOLAR POWER FROM SPACE IS POTENTIALLY TRANSFORMATIONAL
George Freeman MP
Minister for Science, Research and Innovation

Two examples were highlighted at the conference – GHGSat and SatelliteVu. GHGSat now has three satellites in space, monitoring methane emissions from industrial facilities and landfill. Meanwhile SatelliteVu, which is set to launch its first IR imagery satellite next year in a SpaceX rocket, is set to offer 3.5m resolution thermal imagery to detect energy efficiencies of individual buildings and factories. Anthony Baker, Founder & CEO, SatelliteVu, told the conference that there was increasing interest from the finance sector in this high-resolution thermal imaging capability.

Indeed, the exploitation and use of EO satellite data and imagery, not only by climate scientists, but by financiers, banks, investors and insurers to understand and assess the risk of clients, their climate change policies and proposed infrastructure projects was a recurring theme at the conference. There is now an “increasing relationship” between the finance and space EO sector, said Telespazio’s Alexandra Barker, EO & Climate Marketing, with companies wanting to understand and reduce their climate footprint. John Firth, Senior Director, Climate & Resilience Hub, Willis Towers Watson, agreed, saying that investors are now screening new potential investment projects by running them through climate change risk tools.

This EO revolution even extends to using imagery to measure economic activity, with the US Federal Reserve Bank using satellite data to help calculate a country’s GDP as light pollution from space closely tracks GDP.

Inmarsat chief warns of megaconstellation risk

President Howard Nye FRAeS opens the conference.

While the focus of the conference was on satellites’ ability to monitor climate change, delegates heard a stark warning that the space sector is also creating new forms of pollution, such as the growing threat of space junk from planned mega-constellations such as Starlink, OneWeb, Amazon and Chinese projects.

Satellite operator, Inmarsat’s CEO Rajeev Suri told delegates: “For space to support sustainability on Earth, there needs to be sustainability in space and to be blunt, we are moving in the wrong direction here.” He outlined three concerns – space debris, atmospheric pollution and ‘orbital exclusion’. Suri said of plans for 100-200,000 satellite megaconstellations: “We simply do not yet understand all the risks this creates” in terms of space debris and ‘orbital exclusion’ by these projects taking up valuable orbital slots in LEO, that other space users will have to pass through to get to higher orbits.

Calling for regulatory oversight, Suri also pointed to the potential for atmospheric pollution in the upper atmosphere by satellites shedding aluminium at high altitude during re-entry and thus increasing solar radiation.

Solar power from orbit

Yet, perhaps the boldest and most inspirational presentation and panel came on the second day of the conference when Martin Soltau, Frazer-Nash Consultancy and Co-Chair of UK’s Space Energy Initiative explained to the audience and virtual delegates how zero-carbon solar power beamed directly from orbit now appears technologically feasible and affordable. The Space Energy Initiative itself is no crank inventor but a partnership of 53 major UK space companies and universities, such as Airbus, Reaction Engines, SSTL, Oxford Space Systems and more who believe that space-based solar power (SBSP) could be providing cheap power to the UK by the 2040s. The key is rapidly falling launch costs, new technologies, such as in-orbit manufacturing and a scalable 360º phased array antenna that would allow the technology to be proven with smaller SBSP satellites first.

A study by Frazer-Nash on SBSP featured an orbital power station with a 1.7km wide array, but ‘hyper-modular’ and magnetically clipped together for easy assembly. This would harness 24/7 solar power from the Sun which would be beamed back to Earth by microwave at 80% efficiency. Collected by ‘rectennas’ on the ground, the low-power microwaves would be safe and harmless, yet still be able to pass through clouds and rain. Furthermore, the low-cost ground rectennas, which are a fraction of the size of a wind farm, could theoretically allow SBSP operators to export cheap energy to any country on Earth, without oil tankers, pipelines or power lines.

Above: Net zero spin-off; A SBSP study from Frazer Nash looked at harnessing the power of the Sun; The cooling foil from Reaction Engines uses technology developed from its SABRE hybrid engine to improve thermal management

This concept is now rapidly gaining credibility among scientists and momentum among decisionmakers, with George Freeman MP, Minister for Science, Research and Innovation, telling delegates: “The ability to harness solar power from space is potentially transformational”.

Even more excitingly, SBSP also provides potentially the perfect business case for high-frequency, reusable space launchers, such as SpaceX’s Starship and, further in the future, Reaction Engines’ Skylon. These next-gen launchers are searching for customers who need to put 1,000s of tonnes of cargo into orbit which will bring the kg to orbit cost down drastically by repeated flights. Meanwhile, SBSP developers are looking for launch providers able to offer large-capacity, low-cost access to orbit. This need not involve giant fleets of rockets from the outset. Reaction Engines’ Chief Technical Officer, Richard Varvill, noted that construction of an SBSP could start small, with four sats a year but would then grow to 1,000 spaceplane flights and a fleet of 25 Skylon vehicles.

Could, then, SBSP be the use case that, not only helps Earth decarbonise and save the planet but, also helps unlock a brand new era of cheap space travel? Sam Alden, Satellite Applications Catapult thought so, saying SBSP will be “THE big driver driving the space economy – its truly transformational”.

Summary

In summary, this conference gave a fascinating insight into how space will be a key enabler in helping the world meet its net-zero promises and save the planet. Like Cold War arms’ treaties, satellites with their all-seeing eyes will allow for ‘trust but verify’ and be able to measure and monitor our progress on decarbonisation. However, perhaps most revolutionary of all, the long-awaited promise of SBSP now appears feasible - cheap, clean, interruptible power from orbit - which could then unlock a wider space economy. As one delegate enthused to the SBSP panel: “This is the biggest opportunity in space we have had in decades - how do we make it happen?”